Should EU citizens living in other member states vote there in national elections? - Duff
- Should EU citizens living in other member states vote there in national elections?
- Rainer Bauböck: EU citizens should have voting rights in national elections, but in which country?
- Alain Brun: A European or a national solution to the democratic deficit?
- Andrew Duff: EU accession to the ECHR requires ensuring the franchise for EU citizens in national elections
- David Owen: How to enfranchise second country nationals? Test the options for best fit, easiest adoption and lowest costs
- Dimitry Kochenov: What’s in a People? Social Facts, Individual Choice, and the European Union
- Jo Shaw: Testing the bonds of solidarity in Europe’s common citizenship area
- Richard Bellamy: 'An ever closer union among the peoples of Europe': Union citizenship, democracy, rights and the enfranchisement of Second Country Nationals
- Kees Groenendijk: Five pragmatic reasons for a dialogue with and between member states on free movement and voting rights
- Hannes Swoboda: Don’t start with Europeans first. An initiative for extending voting rights should also promote access to citizenship for third country nationals
- Martin Wilhelm: Voting rights and beyond...
- Dora Kostakopoulou: One cannot promote free movement of EU citizens and restrict their political participation
- Ángel Rodríguez: Second country EU citizens voting in national elections is an important step, but other steps should be taken first
- Sue Collard: A more comprehensive reform is needed to ensure that mobile citizens can vote
- Tony Venables: Incremental changes are not enough - voting rights are a matter of democratic principle
- Roxana Barbulescu: Mobile Union citizens should have portable voting rights within the EU
- Concluding remarks by Philippe Cayla and Catriona Seth: Righting democratic wrongs
- All Pages
EU accession to the ECHR requires ensuring the franchise for EU citizens in national elections
by Andrew Duff (MEP, Liberal Democrat, UK)
Another hopeful event is the prospect of the EU signing up to the ECHR (and its First Protocol). This will, in my view, allow disenfranchised citizens to seek a remedy at the European Court of Justice at Luxembourg and/or the European Court of Human Rights at Strasbourg by demanding that the EU now has a duty to act to guarantee 'conditions which will ensure the free expression of the opinion of the people in the choice of the legislature'.
With that in mind, I recently asked a written question of the European Commission as follows:
"All Member States have adopted the first Protocol to the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR), Article 3 of which states that: 'The High Contracting Parties undertake to hold free elections at reasonable intervals by secret ballot, under conditions which will ensure the free expression of the opinion of the people in the choice of the legislature'.The answer of Commission Vice-President Reding, (E-9269/2011, 2 February 2011) was somewhat disappointing. Here it is:
"In view of the imminent likely accession of the European Union to the ECHR and to its first Protocol, what does the Commission intend to do about member states who disenfranchise their own nationals who choose to live in another EU state for an extended period?
"Likewise, what does it intend to do to encourage EU states to extend the right to vote in national elections to their long-term resident EU citizens of another nationality?
"Does the Commission agree that it is unacceptable that a very large number of EU citizens are deprived of their basic civic right to choose the legislature either of the state in which they live or in their original state?
"Will the Commission be ready to take action to ensure that all EU states comply with the provisions of the ECHR which guarantee the right to vote?"
"As already highlighted in its reply to written question E-7910/2010 by Mr. Jim Higgins and E-8488/2011 by Mr. Morten Løkkegaard, the Commission is aware that national provisions in a number of Member States disenfranchise their nationals due to their residence abroad. Consequently, EU citizens of the Member States concerned cannot participate in any national elections.
"The Commission announced in the EU Citizenship report 2010 report (COM(2010)603) that it would launch a discussion to identify political options to prevent EU citizens from losing their political rights, and namely the right to vote in national elections, as a consequence of exercising their right to free movement. The Commission has recently contacted the concerned Member States to launch this debate and to explore the possible political solutions.
"The Commission has raised at this occasion that, while organisation of national elections falls within the responsibilities of Member States, if citizens cannot participate in electing Member States government, nor in their Member State of origin or the Member State of residence, and thus are not represented in the Council of Ministers, these citizens cannot fully participate in the democratic life of the Union.
"The Commission would like to inform that the accession to the ECHR will not extend the European Union competences as defined in the Treaties. In particular, the accession to the First Protocol of the Convention neither will extend the right to vote of EU citizens residing outside their Member State to national parliamentary elections, nor enable Commission to take actions against Member states' violations of Article 3 of this Protocol."